
Katie Nixon, CFA, CPWA®, CIMA®
Chief Investment Officer, Northern Trust Wealth Management
This morning’s unexpectedly weak August nonfarm payroll report revealed sustained deterioration in the labor market, leading investors to conclude that a September rate cut is imminent and a path of more aggressive cutting could be on the table. In this Weekly Five we discuss our key takeaways, including the impact on the Treasury curve; the continued outperformance of U.S. equities; and our real asset update.
What are your key takeaways from August’s nonfarm payroll report?
The U.S. labor market is exhibiting some worrisome trends with a sharp deceleration in jobs growth, evident in the August nonfarm payroll report. The U.S. economy added only 22,000 jobs during the month — well below expectations of a relatively weak increase of 77,000. There were notable job losses in manufacturing and very anemic gains in healthcare, which had been a meaningful tailwind to labor demand. The unemployment rate climbed to 4.3%, and the June data was revised to show a loss of 13,000 jobs, which was the first negative jobs print since December 2020. This brought the three-month moving average for job creation to only 30,000. While the unemployment rate ticked higher in the aggregate, it is worth noting that the unemployment rate for 16- to 24-year-olds sits at over 10%, reflecting the difficulty that college graduates and other young workers are facing in today’s labor market.
Interestingly, wages were fairly steady: Average hourly earnings rose 0.3% month-over-month and were up 3.7% at an annualized rate. This is slightly down from July’s pace of 3.9%, but not at a level that suggests significant weakness. It may be that, just as demand for labor has eased, supply has also eased due to tighter immigration policies.
How is labor market weakness likely to affect Fed policy in September and in the balance of 2025?
Fed Chair Powell’s Jackson Hole speech and recent comments from FOMC members suggest that weakening jobs data will be more influential on monetary policy than fears of higher tariff-related inflation, which is assumed to be fleeting. The Fed’s focus will be on the slowdown in job creation, and this should be enough to urge them to ease policy in September. The market is now pricing in two to three rate cuts through the end of the year: This is slightly more aggressive than before the jobs report was released, which seems reasonable. The data-dependent Fed now has a few months of data reflecting weakness in the foundation of the U.S. economy — jobs. Moreover, the weakness in the labor market may prompt criticism that the Fed is behind the curve.
The Weekly Five
Put recent portfolio performance in context with market and economic analysis that goes beyond the headlines.
What was the impact on the Treasury curve, and what does this mean for borrowers?
Changing rate expectations have been quickly reflected in the U.S. Treasury yield curve: The 2-year yield fell a full 10 basis points to 3.48% as the jobs report hit the wires, and the 10-year followed suit, falling more than 8 basis points to 4.07% as investors expressed increased concern over recession risk and increased confidence in a more aggressive policy easing from the Fed. A silver lining for borrowers is the decline in the 10-year yield, which was close to 4.5% in July: It is being reflected in the decline in mortgage rates, which have fallen to their lowest levels since 2024. Lower borrowing costs may provide support to housing demand, offering a much needed stimulus to the sluggish market.
What’s driving U.S. equity performance amid a complex economic backdrop?
U.S. equity markets continue to reach and breach record highs, buoyed by strong corporate earnings, intense momentum behind AI-related stocks, and expectations of easier monetary policy going forward. Since June, the S&P 500 advanced over 5% through yesterday’s close, with growth stocks outperforming their value counterparts by roughly 1%. The 6.7% advance of the NASDAQ reflects investors’ continued preference for growth stocks, particularly in the tech sector. Interestingly, small caps have finally gotten attention, and their nearly 10% gain since June has come after a long period of underperformance. Lower interest rates are considered to be a tailwind to these companies, which tend to be more highly leveraged, and the general “risk-on” tone of the market is also supportive of the riskiest stocks.
Although non-U.S. stocks continue to post impressive results, the relative performance since June favors the U.S.: Broad Emerging Market indices have advanced 3.8% since June and Developed ex-U.S. benchmarks have gained just over 2%.
How did real assets perform in August?
August performance was mixed, with global real estate and global natural resources outperforming global equities, while global listed infrastructure and commodities lagged. Listed infrastructure underperformed broader equities, with strong performance in non-U.S. sectors while the U.S. component ended August in the red. While lower interest rates on the shorter end of the yield curve was a tailwind to certain asset classes, stubbornly high longer-term rates had a negative impact on infrastructure. Finally, natural resources had strong results globally, with metals and mining providing performance tailwinds.